David Thomson

Paradise Lost

'Top of the Lake' ends as a beautiful mess

After its two-part conclusion on Monday night, Top of the Lake seems imperfect, but so is life and so are the mountains in the show—they are wild, insisting on shapes of their own. The show was ragged, too, and the channel showing it was tattered yet strident. You could despair of those things, or begin to see them as part of the message. I don’t know whether Jane Campion selected this narrative autism in advance, or to what extent it was happenstance or mistake.

READ MORE >>

The 'Gatsby' Baz Luhrmann Should Have Made

Forget DiCaprio—The Movie Needs Bernie Madoff

Forget DiCaprio—what we really need is a modern-day Gatsby. Bernie Madoff could take a supporting role.

READ MORE >>

Apocalypses Now

Hollywood action movies need to get over the end of the world

So who is green-lighting these end-of-the-world movies that just keep coming—Oblivion, After Earth, Star Trek Into Darkness, Olympus Has Fallen, White House Down, World War Z, Pacific Rim? Is it the triumvirate of David Stockman, Paul Krugman, and Kim Jong-un? I grant that Armageddon has been a recurring theme on screen.

READ MORE >>

He was famous as a TV figure, but he would tell you always that he was a newspaper man.

READ MORE >>

Why Jane Campion's turn to television isn't a complete success, while David Mamet's was.

READ MORE >>

Derek Cianfrance's America

Class and fate in 'The Place Beyond the Pines'

For the second time, Derek Cianfrance has put Ryan Gosling on the edge of a great character: the American failure who has the neediness and the inner life of a wild genius. 

READ MORE >>

Why 'The Shining' Continues to Shine

A documentary pays tribute to Kubrick and parodies film commentary

As a documentary about The ShiningRoom 237 is a tribute to Kubrick and a parody of film commentary.

READ MORE >>

The acclaimed director of "Oldboy" stumbles in his American debut.

READ MORE >>

What's Isabelle Huppert Doing in This Third-Rate Thriller?

'Dead Man Down' and the inanities of Hollywood casting

"Dead Man Down" is dark, nasty, violent, and laughably boring. It also features one of the best actresses in the world.

READ MORE >>

The "red coat" girl of Schindler's List now says she's horrified by the movie she filmed when she was twelve. Should Spielberg have shot the vulgar scene to begin with?

READ MORE >>

Pages

SHARE HIGHLIGHT

0 CHARACTERS SELECTED

TWEET THIS

POST TO TUMBLR