JONATHAN CHAIT JULY 16, 2010
-
Read Later
READ LATERAvailable only to subscribers. SUBSCRIBE TODAY
-
Listen
ARTICLE AUDIO
- Font Size
The Republicans' new non-white candidates have drawn a lot of attention, but Peter Beinart notes that the party's religious litmus tests remain in full force:
Jindal was raised Hindu and converted to Catholicism; Haley is a Sikh who became evangelical. There’s no reason to doubt the sincerity of their conversions. But both also seem aware that maintaining the non-Western religious traditions of their birth would have imperiled their political careers. In 2007, when Congress overwhelmingly passed a resolution recognizing the Hindu and Sikh festival of Diwali, Jindal abstained. Before running for governor, Haley noted that her family attended a Sikh Temple as well as a Methodist Church, but today she studiously avoids any reference to being born Sikh and as the campaign has progressed, her website has been updated to stress in increasingly emphatic terms her devotion to Jesus Christ.
He also has a nice rebuttal of the absurd Noemie Emery:
As the conservative columnist Noemie Emery recently declared, “Diversity has struck the Republican Party, but to the parties it means different things. Democrats see it as an end in itself…Republicans see it as the means to an end, i.e., more good candidates…Democrats organize themselves by identity interests; Republicans by ideology.”
On one level, Emery’s statement is absurd, since if Democrats really saw diversity as “an end in itself,” which matters more than ideology, they’d be supporting the Republicans’ female, minority candidates over their own white male ones.
3 comments
I could be wrong, but I think Haley's and Jindal's religious positioning may have as much to do with running for office in Louisiana and South Carolina as with running in Republican primaries. For instance, Democrats have also fielded a South Asian candidate for a Louisiana congressional seat who notes his Catholicism on his website. http://www.raviforcongress.com/about/ I do think that a Muslim running for office in a Republican primary would likely face severe obstacles, even if he was running in California. That said, animus toward
- bgbryant
July 16, 2010 at 5:15pm
I'm a big Beinart booster, but I think he's a little too strong in his conclusion here. Just because the GOP still has some unfair attitudes doesn't mean it has nothing "to crow about". Nominating the daughter of a Sikh is a pretty big deal! Especially when half the right's argument against Obama was that he's the son of Muslim Marxist. No need to trivialize such large steps in the right direction.
- Simon Greenwood
July 16, 2010 at 6:41pm
Noemi Emery is absurd. I enjoyed you blowing her out of the water with her own statement. I would never carry a gun around you, J. You'd have it out of my holster in no time flat and then you would turn it on me.
- liberal reformer
July 16, 2010 at 9:17pm