THE STASH DECEMBER 9, 2009
-
Read Later
READ LATERAvailable only to subscribers. SUBSCRIBE TODAY
-
Listen
ARTICLE AUDIO
- Font Size
Financial Times columnist Martin Wolf has a particularly good summary today of the danger that China’s undervalued currency poses to the world economy. As Wolf points out, China’s “real exchange rate is … no higher than in early 1998 and has depreciated by 12 per cent over the past seven months, even though China has the world’s fastest-growing economy and largest current account surplus.” That means, in effect, that China is levelling a large, uniform tariff on imports (whose price is higher than they should be relative to China’s goods) and granting a large subsidy to its own exports. That could prevent full-scale recovery in many of the world’s economies, including that of the United States, and could eventually hamper China’s growth as well.
During Barack Obama’s visit to China last month, the Chinese tried to deflect attention from its overvalued currency and huge surpluses by attacking the U.S. for putting tariffs on Chinese tire imports. As Wolf points, American protectionism is small potatoes compared to what the Chinese are doing. Obama, unfortunately, seems to have taken the bait and played down – publicly, at least – American disatisfaction with Chinese economic policies, preferring to focus instead on the relatively tame issue of internet censorship. That may have pleased democracy advocates and Silicon Valley, but Obama’s protest will have little effect, while ignoring the most important source of global friction.
2 comments
Could someone explain to be the following?: 1) How do mercantile economies like China (along with Japan and some other Asian countries) manipulate their currencies so effectively, when relatively open Western economies like the US or the EU can't? 2) How they get away with it year in-year out for decades with the rest of the world doing next to nothing (I would say absolutely nothing)? It never was the West's interest to allow this go on for so long unchallenged. I just do not understand how they get away with it. Sooner or later the system has to crack and when it does no one will win.
- tnmats
December 9, 2009 at 9:37am
I fail to see how publicly exhorting Beijing to let its currency rise would actually accomplish said goal. Authoritarian regimes have one interest above all: to preserve their own power. Letting the yuan appreciate does not pose a challenge to that. To be seen as kowtowing to American demands does. It's likely we can gradually persuade China that it's in its own interest to relax some currency controls, but if so it's going to be done quietly and behind closed doors. The lack of public bluster does not equal the lack of action, especially since we have virtually no leverage to back up that bluster. We can take no concrete steps to punish China that wouldn't ultimately be counterproductive at best, self-damaging at worst.
- adaglas
December 9, 2009 at 10:07am