SUBSCRIBE NOW WELCOME BACK. Do you want to continue reading where you left off? New Republic subscribers can pick up where they left off no matter which device they were previously using. SUBSCRIBE NOW

Go Home How Safe Are Cruise Ships?

THE STUDY JANUARY 16, 2012

How Safe Are Cruise Ships?

Bad weather is preventing rescuers from reaching the wreckage of the Costa Concordia, a luxury cruise ship that crashed off the Italian coast on Friday. Blame for the disaster, which has claimed at least six lives, is increasingly falling on the ship’s captain, who allegedly took the ship off-course and abandoned it before all the passengers were evacuated. The disaster has sparked outrage among officials and worry in the cruise industry, which is in the midst of its busiest season. How safe are cruise ships?

A 2004 article in Tourism Management suggests that while cruise vacations are generally safe, there are nonetheless gaps in some safety measures. One area of concern is the growing number of passengers on cruise ships: By 1999, there were nine million every year, and that number likely doubled during the 2000s. This growing number of “large and diverse groups of people,” the study says, “means that their officers, staff and crew need a clear understanding of human responses in emergencies and an ability to deal with crowds.” Effective emergency management requires extensive crew training, clear lines of communication, and proficiency in the use of various kinds of technology. Sadly, the chaos described by passengers on the Costa Concordia suggests that the ship’s captain and crew were simply not ready for this disaster. 

SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS

Show all 4 comments

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

4 comments

Hmm... 1. Life is dangerous. No one gets out alive. 2. People live much longer than they used to (in general). 3. In the past, human life was fairly cheap. People died in genocides and wars, of preventable diseases, digging mines and building railroads, in childbirth, and so on. Now that we are harder to knock off so easily, life is becoming more precious. We are taking greater exception to accidents (such as the Cruise Ship fiasco) that knock off humans carelessly, but also worrying about our non-human companions. My local public library branch has a display up touting the benefits of vegetarianism and veganism; my wife would not dream of eating one of our hens and weeps when one of them gets sick or has an accident and expires. 4. Soon each new child will be wrapped in cotton wool shorty after birth and perpetually guarded by a robot-android duenna who strives to protect the child from any misfortune so it can live forever. 5. One of the books sitting on my bookshelf (so far unfinished) is The Singularity is Near by Ray Kurzweill. Mr. Kurzweill believes that in a few decades humans will merge with artificial intelligences and become immortal. 6. I am a suspicious non-believing cynic. I do not believe in God, Heaven or Hell, or life after death. I doubt that Mr. Kurzweill (who is, admittedly a very bright man and much smarter than I am) is correct in his optimism. Either he is a) incorrect and will die (like the rest of us) one of these days or b) he is dangerously sort of correct and will, in fact, succeed in creating something like the up to now imaginary concept of Hell in reality. 7. In any case, be careful, whether you take a cruise ship, ride on an airplane, walk down the street, or get up out of bed tomorrow morning. Good luck.

- skahn

January 16, 2012 at 7:24pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

Respectfully, what does this have to do with the senseless loss of life due to negligence, apparently, on this particular ship? There's no way it should have run aground and the crew should have been prepared. No doubt, it's better than the Titanic. Tell it to the people who lost their loved ones, skahn.

- Sophia

January 16, 2012 at 11:44pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

Sophia, thank you for your comment. As far as I know, we cannot go back and change the past. Not in Italy, and not even where we live. All we can do is live in the present and sensibly prepare for the future, which none of us can see with great certainty. I take fish oil and a baby aspirin each day. I fasten my seat belt and shoulder harness when I drive, and try to focus on the road and not distract myself by talking on the telephone. I start my generator once a month (outside the basement, so I don't carbon monoxide myself). I have a storage tank of water outside our house in case of earthquake because when the power goes out, our well does not work. I volunteer for the local Red Cross because I am not smart enough, not skillful enough, and not knowledgeable enough to serve as a "first responder" or "second responder." What do you do? (I don't mean this as a "third degree," or as an insult; I suspect you do sensible things to prepare for future personal and community calamities.) While I have no admiration for, no excuse for, and no defense of the captain and crew of the Italian cruise liner that ran aground and caused loss of life, I will politely suggest that none of us can ever be sure that someone will not someday be saying to you or I something along the lines of "Tell it to the people who lost their loved ones, skahn or Sophia."

- skahn

January 17, 2012 at 1:56pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

Skahn the behavior of your arteries is not a commercial enterprise, making a profit, and you don't have a choice about aging.

- Sophia

January 17, 2012 at 3:45pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

SHARE HIGHLIGHT

0 CHARACTERS SELECTED

TWEET THIS

POST TO TUMBLR

SHARE ON FACEBOOK

Close