SUBSCRIBE NOW WELCOME BACK. Do you want to continue reading where you left off? New Republic subscribers can pick up where they left off no matter which device they were previously using. SUBSCRIBE NOW

Go Home Winning Immigration

NOVEMBER 5, 2007

Winning Immigration

Dems and Immigration: [Ezra Klein, TAPPED]:
“You will, I'm convinced, need to win the border security debate before you can
get into any of the more humane issues of paths to citizenship and protecting
children. And while saying that Bush and the Republicans have
failed for eight years may have some impact, we won't be running against Bush,
Instead, my hunch is there's room for an argument saying that the modern GOP won't
ever get serious about staunching illegal immigration because their main
supporters large corporations, like the supply of cheap labor.”

 

Playing it Safe: [Steve Clemons, The Washington Note]:
“Obama says he wants to differentiate himself from Hillary Clinton now -- but he's
doing it in lukewarm, safe ways. He has my whole-hearted support in his views
on reframing America's Cuba policy--but he's still sort of squishy on
Iran.
He believes in vigorous, aggressive engagement--but what about doing
something real to preclude a war in the next year?”

 

Myopia: [Dick Polman, Dick Polman’s American Debate]: “Does
that sound like anybody we know? With the same propensity for quoting military
statistics, while saying nothing about the dearth of political reconciliation
in Baghdad--which was why the surge was launched in the first place? This is Thompson’s
dilemma, one he shares with his rivals: whoever does manage to mollify the
religious/social conservative base, and win the nomination, must then compete
in the general election. And parroting President Bush on Iraq, as Thompson did yesterday,
will be bad salesmanship.”

 

Catching Up: [Todd Beeton, MyDD]: “As I wrote last
week, the recent Quinnipiac poll concluded that the stepped up attacks on Clinton were taking a toll and these new polls confirm
that her level of support has returned to where she was in August and
September, before Obama and Edwards began to step up their criticism of Clinton. To be fair, a
20+ point lead is still significant but the question remains whether this is a
downward trend for Clinton
or if it's merely a correction. At best, Clinton's
inevitability train has been momentarily stalled.”

 

--Ben Crair

SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS

Show 1 comment

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

1 comments

Democrats are losing the immigration issue because they're completely out of tune with America! Americans don't mind EVENTUAL amnesty, but they want enforcement FIRST. Enforcement first polls at almost 70%!  You have several groups that have an interest in this issue (at least in my opinion):

10% of america - racists who just hate hispanics

50% of america - non-racists who have an interest in border security and fairness

10% of america - lefties (including african americans) who understand that indescriminately open borders depress low skill wages

10% of america - recent immigrants who support open borders and amnesty

15% of america - lefties who are mostly uninterested in the immigration issue, but buy the racial identify politics appeals of elites and support amnesty because of their traditional support for racial minorities

5% of america - Big business/Wall Street Republicans - want cheaper labor

If you add that up, it comes out to 70% enforcement first, and 30% pro-amnesty.

At any rate, the Democrats are on the wrong side of this issue. The american people want to believe that their national border means something. They want to let plenty of immigrants into this country, but they want it to be done fairly. I don't think that's unreasonable.

Imagine if we tightened the borders significantly. While the price of a few select goods would rise marginally, low skill wages would rise at late 90s levels! Come on Democrats...get with it!

- virginiacentrist

November 5, 2007 at 4:17pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

SHARE HIGHLIGHT

0 CHARACTERS SELECTED

TWEET THIS

POST TO TUMBLR

SHARE ON FACEBOOK

Close