SUBSCRIBE NOW WELCOME BACK. Do you want to continue reading where you left off? New Republic subscribers can pick up where they left off no matter which device they were previously using. SUBSCRIBE NOW

Go Home Greenland Dispatch: Europe's Last Colony And The Big Melt

THE VINE NOVEMBER 14, 2008

Greenland Dispatch: Europe's Last Colony And The Big Melt

Alexander Zaitchik is a freelance journalist based in New York City. He visited Greenland in August as part of an official press delegation sponsored by the island's home-rule government.

It's become a cliché of Arctic reportage to begin stories by describing the calving of glaciers—that process by which enormous vertical slabs of ice, some as tall as skyscrapers, slice off the glacial shelf and collapse into the waiting sea. During a recent reporting trip to Greenland, I quickly understood the impulse to chronicle this phenomenon. Even more than a Cat-5 hurricane making landfall, watching the muffled collapse of the ice shelves is like staring into the cold black eyes of climate change itself. It's the world literally breaking up, falling apart—albeit with surprising grace.

As everyone from Roland Emmerich to Al Gore has now publicized, Greenland's glaciers are crumbling in the north, and retreating farther and farther up the fjords in the south. The winter freeze every year becomes less reliable, making snowmobile and dog-sled traffic between remote villages impossible. Most shocking for Greenland's 57,000 residents, the growing season is elongating, allowing for the cultivation of once-exotic crops like broccoli and cabbage. "We may have our own wine industry one day," a restaurant owner in the southwestern town of Qaqortoq told me with pride and wonder.

But it's not just the wine industry that depends on Greenland's Great Melt. So, too, does the island's dream of independence from Denmark, which has governed Greenland as a colony more or less continuously since the eighteenth-century. Greenland has pinned its hopes for a future as a self-sustaining state on the vast mineral and oil reserves that are now becoming accessible as the ice thaws—reserves that could one day make Kuwait look like Botswana. And, so, on November 25, Greenlanders will vote on an autonomy referendum that will move the country further along the path to independence: A "yes" vote would grant Greenland's home-rule government the rights to most of the future royalties from these mineral and oil reserves.

This bounty may become exposed sooner than many thought possible. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration recently reported that this year's autumn temperatures in the Arctic were 5 degree Celsius higher than normal, a new record. The news caused climate scientists to revise their predictions in favor of faster warming and glacial retreat—an alarming fact for most of the world, but welcome news in Greenland. "Keep running your air-conditioning machines. Keep driving your cars," grinned Mininnguaq Kleist, an official in the Office of Self-Governance in Nuuk. "The melting is opening up access to natural resources and creating possibilities for new ports and trade routes. This is a good thing for us and we shouldn't pretend it isn't."

I encountered more official optimism about global warming in the inner sanctum of Nuuk's city hall, which looks like an Inuit Security Council chamber, with a circular seminar table centered by a polar-bear-skin rug and flanked by walrus tusks and knitted seal-hunting pastorals. It was there that I met with Asii Chemnitz Narup, the incoming mayor of Nuuk, the largest and least-populated municipality in the world. "We must be open to the positive effects of climate change in helping develop our small economy," said Narup. "There will be gold, rubies, and diamond mines in the south. Zinc deposits in the north. And oil. The potential is enormous."

So it is. In the biggest project of the unfolding first wave of multinational ventures in Greenland, Alcoa is set to open a mine and aluminum plant near Qaqortoq (population 3,100), to be plumbed by 2,000 Chinese migrant workers. Meanwhile, dozens of oil and excavation firms are busy prospecting along every coast, waiting for world prices to make exploration and direct investment in Greenland profitable. The biggest prize, as any Greenlandic official will tell you with gleaming eyes, is oil. A U.S. Geological Survey suggests that the waters around the northeast of the island could contain up to 110 billion barrels—around half the reserves of Saudi Arabia. Oil companies are feverishly collecting fresh seismic data from different parts of Greenland, ready to pounce on the latest concession offered by the Bureau of Minerals and Petroleum. Burning the oil will, of course, only accelerate the warming trends that made its discovery possible, bringing humanity's climate tragicomedy full-circle.

But the irony is deeper than most realize. As the melting ice cap threatens to inundate coastal lands around the planet, Greenland itself will actually rise, as the weight of the ice cap lightens. "The ice is so heavy that it's keeping us at an artificially low sea-level," explained Alfred Jakobsen, a scientist with the Ministry of Environment. "As the ice melts, Greenland is lifting up, up, out of the sea." It's possible that at some point in the next century or two, Greenland will emerge from flyover obscurity to become one of the most desirable plots of real estate on Earth: a vast, temperate, uninhabited, and clean-aired island haven—at least for those who can afford it. According to Greenland's tourist office, Bill Gates and the Google twins have been enjoying the island's remote and expensive pleasures for years. It's easy to think that the American billionaires are as far ahead of the global curve as the Greenlanders, with their dog sleds, seal hunts, and oil dreams, are behind it.

SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS

Show all 8 comments

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

8 comments

Um, they do understand that once they start extracting and burning all that oil, they won't be any kind of "clean-aired" anything, don't they?

- cspencef

November 14, 2008 at 9:43pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

So we have plans underway to conquer and occupy Greenland right?

- Maxblum13

November 15, 2008 at 4:09am

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

One question: why is this a blog post?  Here you have a well-written, well-REPORTED piece on a subject most of us know little about--why didn't the editors give Zaitchik space in the mag?  

I appreciate the effort you're making over here at The Vine, Brad, but I'm puzzled by the blog's relationship to TNR as a whole.  It seems to me that TNR has cultivated a stable of young writers with a real interest in and depth of knowledge about the environment, a constellation of problems that are possibly the most significant issues facing humanity right now and yet that remain underreported.  And yet, you're largely relegated to this blog.  It seems to me you should be getting out of the office actually to report on some of these stories, like the one on the coal-fired PP ruling above.  TNR has Jon Cohn covering the healthcare beat, why not Brad Plummer on the environment?  What's missing at the moment is depth and originality.  Too much of The Vine is just recycling other publications' scoops.

Maybe it's a budget issue.  The New Yorker is running safely in the black, but I know from personal sources that Remnick is scared shitless about how the economic downturn will effect the magazine's bottom line.  I imagine TNR is flying even closer to the treetops.  Even so, if you're not giving value for money, you can't hope to stay in business.  Get out there Brad!  Get the stories!  And if they only give you a $400 expense account, get out there anyway!  Two words: Greyhound and GORP.

- aeromonas

November 15, 2008 at 6:20pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

Seriously - why don't we send a few thousand Americans over there now, start printing passports for the rest of the people there in a couple of years, and then annex the whole thing a few years after that? Who's going to stop us? Denmark?

- Maxblum13

November 15, 2008 at 7:05pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

ach year, the winery hosts a joyous blues festival, a legendary Fourth of July party, and the massive Bluegrass n’ BBQ festival that often features national acts like David Grisman, Laurie Lewis or the Austin Lounge Lizards. There are other intriguing

- Anonymous

November 17, 2008 at 12:04pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

kosher wines Israel - Interesting perspective.  I'd be interested to hear your opinion on other environmental issues.

aero - I never knew "gorp" (I assume you're referring to trail mix) was an acronym; what does it stand for?  And I've been hoping for a while that we'd see more on the environmental front now that the election coverage is finished.  We'll find out shortly if that is so.

- dhauck

November 17, 2008 at 12:29pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

God, I'd hate to be the one that says this, but is the difference between Greenlanders' worldview and Sarah Palin's solely her religious zest, and nothing more?  This sort of hand-clasping excitement over climate change seems just a little too familiar.  

If global trade routes are to be changed (to trader's favor) because of melting caps, as December's Atlantic Monthly proposes, and far northern villages become strategic seaports, then it means that Sarah Palin still holds too much power even as Alaska's governor.  Her ousting is more critical than ever now!

- dylanposer

November 17, 2008 at 6:33pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

Late reply, dahauk, but maybe you'll still see it.  GORP = good old raisins & peanuts.

- aeromonas

November 19, 2008 at 11:04pm

You must be a subscriber to post comments. Subscribe today.

SHARE HIGHLIGHT

0 CHARACTERS SELECTED

TWEET THIS

POST TO TUMBLR

SHARE ON FACEBOOK

Close