The Plank

When Novelists Attack


I really like Winter’s
. But it’s hard to take Mark Helprin seriously--as a thinker, at least--when
in late 2008 he still writes things like this, in today’s Wall
Street Journal

Today's progressives apologize to the
world for America's
treatment of terrorists (not a single one of whom has been executed). Franklin
Roosevelt, when faced with German saboteurs (who had caused not a single
casualty), had them electrocuted and buried in numbered graves next to a sewage


One would hope that someone as brilliant as Helprin had moved beyond the tired, simplistic tropes of the 2004
election. Oh well.


What’s the difference between Helprin and, say, Philip Roth,
who’s also been known to dabble in political debates? Roth never pretends to be
anything other than a novelist. But Helprin, as a senior fellow at the Claremont Institute, wants to be both a
novelist and a serious, strategic thinker. But cheap, anachronistic shots like
this just make him appear tired and inattentive to the, oh, last four years of American
politics. Since this isn’t too far from fiction anyway, maybe he should just
stick with his day job.


--Clay Risen

For more stories, like the New Republic on Facebook:

Loading Related Articles...
The Plank

More articles tagged as

Article Tools