THE SPINE JANUARY 2, 2007
-
Read Later
READ LATERAvailable only to subscribers. SUBSCRIBE TODAY
-
Listen
ARTICLE AUDIO
- Font Size
Teddy Kollek, who served as the mayor of Jerusalem for nearly three decades, died early this morning in the city that he loved and revived. I had written about him quite often over the years because his life touched mine, and in a significant way: Largely because it meant working with him, I accepted a post as chairman of the Jerusalem Foundation in the United States. My God, I served in that position for perhaps a dozen years, during which time I quarreled with many of his underlings but never with him. If anything gets me passed the gates of judgment it will be my labors in his vineyard. And was he a drinker of wine, but only good wine! Also a gourmet and a gourmand. Plus a smoker of Cuban cigars. Nothing but Havanas.
Everything else in his life, I surmise, he did for the Jewish people and for Israel. His wife, long suffering, protected him from his own bad habits. His children (I know the son better than the daughter, but not really well) lived and struggled like the offspring of any titanic father.
And what did he not do for the Jews and for their State! He became a Zionist as a teenager in Vienna, and then emigrated to Palestine. But his early Zionism was a mixture of idealism, historical foresight and resentment at not being allowed into an echt Austrian dueling society. Once in Palestine, he helped found a kibbutz on the Sea of
Galilee. He entered socialist politics, being a chaver (a comrade) of Moshe Dayan, Shimon Peres and the most formidable of that generation Yigal Allon, who died quite young. (Anita Shapira is publishing her biography of Allon in English later this year, I think.) Kollek and Golda Meir disdained each other, for reasons that are understandable but too much shul politik to go into here. But Kollek was the favorite of David Ben-Gurion who was the leader of the Yishuv, the Jewish community in Palestine (in contrast to Chaim Weizmann and Louis Brandeis who led European and American Zionism abroad.) Ben Gurion was the first prime minister of the restored Jewish sovereign polity. Kollek represented B.G. on many missions, both public and, more important, furtive. He was at once brusque and suave. Teddy also liked rich people. He was never really a socialist. He was inured to those illusions, even on the kibbutz where he was a fisherman.
If you read his obituaries you will know what a transformational mayor he was in the Holy City, sensitive for sure to the Muslim Arabs who feel for Jerusalem only when it is in the care of Jews or Christians. That's why, over 14 centuries and more, it was a backwater. To Teddy, Jerusalem was David's city. And here is something Christians might keep in mind: if this city was not Jewish, the whole story of Jesus and the foundations of Christianity are bogus. Kollek has an edifice complex, and the physical evidence of his custodianship rivals that of Herod. But Kollek was a man of culture and taste. He was a Jew from Vienna, after all.
He was also a smuggler, a smuggler of weapons during the state's gestation period and directly afterwards. He was the Jewish defense army's man in New York, the representative of the Haganah, headquartered in Hotel 14 on East 60th Street where the Copacabana was housed. I don't know whether it is there that Teddy met Frank Sinatra. But, someplace, he (and Frank's lawyer Mickey Rudin, but that's another story I'll tell you sometime) lured Sinatra into the illegal gun running racket to Palestine and then to Israel. Italian mafiosi, bound to the longshoremen in Hoboken, ran the contraband. The FBI was tapping everyone's phones. So Sinatra became their ongoing live cross-Hudson contact to shun the feds. He was a faithful friend of Zion till the end. Many years later, I presided at a Jerusalem Foundation dinner at which Sinatra was presented with a medal for his dangerous work. After all, he could have gone to jail. We gave him a renaissance map with the four spheres of the earth converging with Jerusalem at the apex, the center of the world. Here's what the presentation said, "From Jerusalem, city of David, sweet singer of Israel. To Frank Sinatra, sweet singer of America."
And another story. This was told to me by James Jesus Angleton, the Yalie who was one of the higher-up in the OSS and the CIA. He was a poet, a raiser of orchids, a fisherman and also a lover of Israel. Oh, but please don't let me forget: a paranoid about Soviet moles, but a paranoid who turned out to be right. (He also cut the corners of the law, about how the Agency was not allowed to tail Americans in America. He was fired by Gerald Ford for doing exactly that. Another story.) Teddy was the minister of information in the Washington embassy of the new State of Israel. (There's also an interesting tale about the embassy building
29 comments
TEDDY KOLLEK, R.I.P. Yes, he was one of the people I admired when I was growing up and was sorry when he stopped being the Mayor of Jerusalem. He will be missed.
- jacksondyer
January 2, 2007 at 7:14pm
or two, or three
- teplukhin
January 2, 2007 at 7:32pm
Having been exposed as "Homer", Donald Maclean defected to the USSR in 1951, became a Soviet foreign policy hack and stayed there till his death 32 years later. An old prof of mine told of being brough by his soviet counterparts to meet "Comrade Maklin" at a foreign policy institute in Moscow, and it turned out to be the urbane old Brit. UCT (or just a garden-variety snob) to the end, Maclean boasted of his soviet medals that they were reserved for the upper crust of Soviet society. Don't know whether he used the Russian phrase luchshie sort [better sort] or not.
- teplukhin
January 2, 2007 at 7:43pm
He appeared with Kirk Douglas in the 1966 movie "Cast a Giant Shadow." The story dealt with the heroic efforts on behalf of Israel by the former American military officer Mickey Marcus. This film is particularly noteworthy because it was the last major Hollywood production that was unabashedly pro-Zionist. There are some who contend that Anthony Blunt could have cared less about Marxist ideology. He was an arrogant snob who held his fellow British citizens in utter contempt. Blunt also had no interest in living in the Soviet Union. He was well aware that it was not a earthly paradise. And yes, I knew about Michael Straight. He is a harsh reminder that the very flawed Joe McCarthy was right about Communist activity within the government of the United States.
- thomsondavid
January 2, 2007 at 9:12pm
Marty, please, memoirs? You must not deprive us. You knew them all, organize it. You have the time now.
- Nancy Kirk
January 2, 2007 at 9:23pm
If w&w wants us to believe that "luchshie sort" is a "Russian phrase," what trust can we have in his other opinions?
- olez
January 2, 2007 at 9:30pm
I strongly recommend the 1986 movie, "Blunt: The Fourth Man." It starred Ian Richardson as Blunt. Anthony Hopkins portrays his fellow Communist traitor, Guy Burgess. These individuals gave mere lip service to the Marxist doctrine of radical egalitarianism. Such sacrifices were for others. Their own lives were fairly affluent and elitist. They would have not lasted a day in a truly Communistic society.
- thomsondavid
January 2, 2007 at 10:07pm
I am now 99% that you and thomsondavid are one and the same. Isn't this the same sin that got Lee Siegel fired?
- wnalpert
January 3, 2007 at 8:17am
Anyway, please note the stylistic similarities, the timing of the responses to Marty Peretz's drivel - (maybe not this one - I have nothing but respect for the memory of Mr. Kollek) - anyway, those of you at the New Republic should do your duty and investigate.
- wnalpert
January 3, 2007 at 8:20am
Actually, you may be on to something. Either Peretz is thomson or thomson is trying to channel Peretz. Have you noticed that often, thomson is the only poster at The Spine? Sometimes, his string of posts constitute the majority of responses. Foer should investigate, I agree.
- MrCookie1
January 3, 2007 at 9:53am
And often Marty will post at 3AM and surprise! thomsondavid is at the keyboard replying moments later.
- wnalpert
January 3, 2007 at 10:08am
Marty Peretz and I cannot possible be one and the same person. I thankfully never attended Harvard University. Our host, alas, wasted much of his life within its academic walls. Is there an attorney ready to represent me? I am definitely being slandered.
- thomsondavid
January 3, 2007 at 10:43am
who is slandering whom? But, if you aren't Peretz, you need to get some sleep laddie. 3:00 follow ups to Marty is not good for your health, on so many levels...
- MrCookie1
January 3, 2007 at 11:16am
That's exactly what I'd expect Marty to say if challenged. I'll believe you're not Marty only after an internal investigation proves otherwise. Regardless, you ought to get some sleep.
- wnalpert
January 3, 2007 at 11:28am
nashel tvoi slovar', Gospodin Deremoshkin?
- teplukhin
January 3, 2007 at 12:12pm
"These individuals gave mere lip service to the Marxist doctrine of radical egalitarianism. Such sacrifices were for others. Their own lives were fairly affluent and elitist. They would have not lasted a day in a truly Communistic society." Er . . . didn't Burgess, MacLean, and Philby live in the USSR for several decades after they fled? Or maybe your comment is meant more as a traditional Trotskyite critique of the "deformed socialism" in the Soviet Union.
- ironyroad
January 3, 2007 at 12:29pm
I have too much respect for Marty (still, I know...) to slander him with Thomson's association. I mean, MP may skew right one too many times, but he's nowhere near the league of Thomson, Jackson, et al
- achester99
January 3, 2007 at 12:30pm
I don't know. The more I think about it and then take into consideration some stylistic similarities (imitation could be thomson's sincerest form of flattery) and that nagging time issue. I never noticed that but unless thomson is sitting around at all hours, waiting like an adolescent suitor waiting for a call back from his dream girl, then I have some real suspicion that something is up. As much as I dislike Peretz, my instinct tells me that this kind of sock puppetry is not his style but given the degeneration of the old gray cells that has been so evident lately, anything is possible...
- MrCookie1
January 3, 2007 at 12:54pm
Give it a rest, Ken. You're on the point of leaving Cookieville for Cuckooland
- teplukhin
January 3, 2007 at 2:06pm
"Er . . . didn't Burgess, MacLean, and Philby live in the USSR for several decades after they fled?" Not by choice. Burgess, MacLean, and Philby also did not live a truly Communist lifestyle. On the contrary, these individuals lived an elite lifestyle. They most certainly did not endure the depravations of the common citizenry of the Soviet Union.
- thomsondavid
January 3, 2007 at 2:13pm
I think it is interesting point. I never noticed the time issue nor have I really paid attention to the stylistic similarities. What's cuckoo about that? And I do state I think the possibility is slim. This could be one of the most intriguing things on The Spine. I apologize if it offends you tep but you can honestly say that this platform is anything more than an echo chamber? The back and forth is on The Plank and on the various article threads. I like a good mystery and a lighthearted approach to politics and discussion. This little mystery has elements of both. I like it. You obviously don't. We are two very different stylists, I reckon.
- MrCookie1
January 3, 2007 at 2:29pm
I remember reading some 25 years ago that Kollek attended the wedding of Kim Philby and Litzi Friedman during the late '30s. Friedman was an active communist/socialist and there was no way Kollek would not have known Philby's fellow traveling. After returning to London Philby was ordered by his NKVD controllers to divorce Friedman and travel to Spain to report on the civil war and burnish his right-wing credentials. The upshot was that Angleton was meeting Philby as liaison for the British at the same time as he was meeting Kollek liaising for the Israelis. Consequently Kollek must have informed Angleton of Philby's communist past. Speculation on why Angleton would possibly have ignored this ranged from Angleton being a mole himself to Angleton turning Philby and infiltrating him back into the USSR. This would explain why Philby was allowed to settle in Beirut (whence he defected) even after suspicion settled on him as the "fourth man."
- rasboy
January 3, 2007 at 2:38pm
td is sui generis
- teplukhin
January 3, 2007 at 3:15pm
hee, hee. Yes, you are probably correct. That is one way to put it!
- MrCookie1
January 3, 2007 at 3:25pm
"Not by choice. Burgess, MacLean, and Philby also did not live a truly Communist lifestyle. On the contrary, these individuals lived an elite lifestyle. They most certainly did not endure the depravations of the common citizenry of the Soviet Union." A nuanced respose. Fair enough.
- ironyroad
January 3, 2007 at 3:26pm
A nuanced RESPONSE, I meant to write.
- ironyroad
January 3, 2007 at 3:26pm
Thanks to Mr. Peretz for sharing these stories and letting me know about Teddy Kollek and his life. So much and so good. Thanks.
- CRS9TNR
January 3, 2007 at 7:58pm
I don't object to your being alert to possible cases of sock-puppetry. In fact, on a previous occasion you helped me consider whether TULLIUS might not be Joementum in drag. But I join tep in defending thomsondavid of the charge of being a surreptitious voice for Martin Peretz. The two species of evidence I am looking at would be: 1) td rants about race and complains about the portrayal of dark-skinned people as victims. This is completely out of character for mp; and 2) mp's prose syle is much more complex and even convoluted; td's is more simple and straightforward. That they agree a lot is not terrific evidence that they are the same person. I agree with you and williamyard, blackton tep, and hustveit a lot, but no one would confuse us. We all have our own idiosyncracies. In short, to put it graphically, I don't think td would have recognized Teddy Kolleck if he had bit him on the ass.
- JackR
January 4, 2007 at 8:51am
You certainly have a point. He probably would just assume this Kolleck guy was Alger Hiss...
- MrCookie1
January 4, 2007 at 9:37am