JONATHAN CHAIT JANUARY 7, 2011
-
Read Later
READ LATERAvailable only to subscribers. SUBSCRIBE TODAY
-
Listen
ARTICLE AUDIO
- Font Size
The Committee For A Responsible Federal Budget and the Concord Coalition have bestowed a "Fiscy Award" upon, in addition to two others, Paul Ryan for his "frequent efforts to promote fiscal discipline and leadership to restore fiscal health,"
Let us examine those efforts. It's true that Ryan talks about the deficit a lot. It's also true that he has a plan that, though increasing the deficit over the next decade, would decrease it over a very long period of time so long as unspecified, draconian limits on the domestic discretionary spending budget held in place and old people didn't force Congress to do anything about the fact that their Medicare benefits were being cut by 76%.
While we're waiting for Ryan's plan to never be enacted, he has an actual voting record. He voted for all the Bush tax cuts. He favors making them permanent. He opposed the Affordable Care Act and now favors repealing it, at considerable cost to the deficit. He has helped change the House budget rules in order to make it far easier to increase the deficit. He opposes any cuts at all to defense spending.
If this is what counts as "frequent efforts to promote fiscal discipline," I think the country would benefit from less frequency.
3 comments
First off, Paul Ryan should be given an award for increasing the deficit.
- liberal reformer
January 7, 2011 at 10:56am
Ahh yes. Once again Ryan dines on his reputation that is largely self-created. Lets' see he voted to make Bush tax cut perm. Endless wars with no defense cuts, wants zero estate, capital gains taxes, voted for the unpaid Bush perscription plan. In short he is the type of person the Concord Coalition has been fighting against forever...
- MikeB.
January 8, 2011 at 9:21am
It makes perfect sense. Ryan has a separate cerebral cortex that developed out of over-stimulation to Rand group-think that any government outlay to citizens they deem unworthy is considered wasteful and parasitic. Any outlay to multi-national defense contractors & corporations, tax cuts for the top 1%, and government "subsidies" that pick oil (winners) over renewables (losers) is essential government. Therefor cutting your Medicare benefit and slashing healthcare for children is fiscal responsibility.
- singlspeed
January 31, 2011 at 10:11am