Super Typhoon Haiyan Was Not As Large As America

The New Republic

You have read:

0 / 8

free articles in the past 30 days.

Already a subscriber?

Log in here

sign up for unlimited access for just $34.97Sign me up


Super Typhoon Haiyan Was Not As Large As America

A map showing Super Typhoon Haiyan superimposed over the continental United States has gone viral. It's all wrong.

Here's the image, supposedly (actually?) created by the Red Cross:


Now, here's the Philippines over the United States:

And here's Haiyan with respect to the Philippines:

So Haiyan was large, but it was not even CLOSE to the size of the United States. The central dense overcast—the strong convection ringing the eye that's colored black in the hoax—is only about the size of the southern most island of the Philippines, not the entire southeast of the United States.

When I last checked (not long before landfall), hurricane force winds only extended about 50 or 60 miles from the eye. It's one of the most intense storms ever, but it wasn't a continental sized monstrosity. 

So here's Haiyan in full context:

Updated 4:03PM:

Here's another look from the University of Wisconsin's Space Science and Engineering Center. The image on the left superimposes an image of Haiyan over the Gulf of Mexico. For comparison, an actual image of Hurricane Katrina (not at its greatest size, but at its greatest intensity) is on the right:

 Update 4:07PM:

@bran_dj superimposes my original satellite image and map of the United States

Update 5:06PM: The Red Cross issues a correction. They neglected to scale the image:

Earlier today, we posted a map of Typhoon Haiyan comparing the size of the storm to geography of the United States. In the process of making the rest of our maps for our operations in the Philippines, we made a mistake with this one and it was not to scale. We always strive to provide the most accurate information possible and we missed the mark with this one-literally. We would like to apologize for this mistake and thank the people who kindly pointed this out to us. We would like to thank everyone for their patience and their continued support of the American Red Cross. We are working on revising the image so it is correct.

share this article on facebook or twitter

posted in: the plank, politics, super typhoon haiyan, phillipines, red cross

print this article

PHOTO BY Jeoffrey Maitem/Getty Images News/Getty Images
Back to Top